How to Trust Yourself Again After Being Shut Down or Controlled (Where I’m At Today)

Learning how to trust yourself again after being shut down, controlled, or constantly corrected doesn’t happen overnight.

If you’ve ever second-guessed your decisions, looked to others for validation, or felt unsure of your own voice, you’re not alone.

This is what it looked like for me to begin rebuilding self-trust—and how it grew alongside my identity, boundaries, and walk with God.


I Wasn’t Taught to Trust Myself

When I was growing up, trusting myself wasn’t something I learned.

I learned something else instead.

I learned that being right didn’t matter as much as being compliant.

I learned that my decisions were often:

  • challenged
  • corrected
  • or talked in circles until I gave up

There were times I tried to make choices or express what I thought, and it didn’t go well.

So eventually, I stopped trying.

I stopped trusting my own voice.

I was taught to follow directions exactly, to be obedient, and to defer to others.

And over time, I internalized that:

Trusting myself wasn’t a safe or reliable option.


What Happens When You Stop Trusting Yourself

When you don’t trust yourself, everything becomes more difficult.

You second-guess:

  • your decisions
  • your instincts
  • your preferences

You look to other people to tell you:

  • what’s right
  • what’s best
  • what you should do

Even in simple situations, you hesitate.

And over time, you can lose touch with:

  • what you actually think
  • what you actually want

That was me.


Rebuilding Self-Trust Didn’t Start Big

I didn’t suddenly wake up one day confident in my decisions.

It started small.

Very small.

I was pushed—gently, but consistently—to start making everyday decisions.

Things like:

  • What do you want to eat?
  • What do you want to watch?
  • What do you think we should do today?

Those questions sound simple.

But for me, they weren’t.

They felt overwhelming.

Early in this process, it was difficult to make decisions because I truly believed I didn’t care.

I viewed it as being low maintenance. Easygoing.

But looking back, that wasn’t really what was happening.

I had set my voice and my opinion aside a long, long time ago.

So when I was asked what I wanted, it didn’t feel like I didn’t have an answer.

It felt like I didn’t have access to one.

There were even moments where simple choices felt overwhelming.

Things like deciding where to go for dinner or what movie to watch.

And I remember getting frustrated—not at being asked—but at not being able to answer.

There were times I would feel the pressure build to the point where I’d get emotional and even tear up over something that seemed so simple.

That’s how disconnected I had become from my own voice.


It Was Mentally Harder Than I Expected

At first, even answering simple questions felt mentally exhausting.

I would freeze.

I would overthink.

I would feel pressure to “get it right.”

Because for so long, my decisions had been:

  • questioned
  • corrected
  • or overridden

Part of my problem was that even when I answered, I was still answering through the lens of people pleasing.

I wasn’t always answering based on what I actually wanted.

Sometimes my answers and opinions came out shaky—more like questions than statements.

And when they did, I felt anxious.

I found myself hoping it was something the other person liked. Something they agreed with. Something they wanted.

Then I would look at their reaction.

Was that okay?
Did I say the right thing?
Should I change it?

That was a big sign of how little trust I had in myself.

So even when I was safe to choose, my mind didn’t feel safe yet.

That part took time.


Finding My Voice Again

Slowly, I started answering.

At first, it was hesitant.

Sometimes it came out with a shaky voice.

Sometimes I changed my answer after saying it.

Sometimes I still wanted someone else to decide for me.

But I kept going.

And over time, I started to notice something:

I was learning what I actually liked.
What I actually wanted.
What I actually thought.

That wasn’t something I had been connected to before.

And something unexpected started to happen.

When I made simple decisions—and actually stated them instead of questioning them—I felt a sense of excitement.

I found myself celebrating small things.

The celebration became even bigger when I wasn’t just answering a question, but offering a thought or suggestion on my own.

Something as simple as:

“Hey love, let’s have meatloaf tonight with sweet potatoes.”

That might sound small or even mundane.

But for me, that was a milestone.

It meant I was starting to trust myself.

It meant I was finding my voice again.


Trusting Myself Is Still a Process

Even now, I wouldn’t say I’ve fully arrived.

Trusting myself is still something I’m learning every day.

There are still moments where I:

  • second-guess
  • hesitate
  • feel unsure

But it’s different now.

I don’t automatically abandon myself.

I don’t immediately assume I’m wrong.

I pause.

I listen.

And I make a decision anyway.


I Had to Learn to Forgive Myself Too

One thing I didn’t expect was how much self-forgiveness would play into this.

For a long time, I carried a lot of responsibility for what I went through.

I blamed myself for:

  • not speaking up sooner
  • not leaving sooner
  • staying as long as I did
  • not seeing things more clearly
  • even leaving people I loved in the same spot
  • not being able to get them to understand

And that made it even harder to trust myself.

Because if I believed I had “failed” in the past, then how could I trust myself moving forward?

But over time, I started to understand something:

I wasn’t operating from clarity back then.

I was operating from what I had been taught… what I had experienced… and what I believed at the time.

I didn’t stay because I was weak.

I stayed because I didn’t yet know what I know now.

And that matters.

Because you can’t expect past decisions to reflect growth you hadn’t experienced yet.


There was another layer to this too.

Because I didn’t trust myself, it also made it harder at times to trust people who were actually trying to pour into my life.

There were moments where I questioned it.

Would they treat me the same way?
Would this turn into something controlling or confusing again?

Part of me didn’t know how to receive something healthy yet.

Not because it wasn’t real.

But because I was still learning how to discern the difference.

That’s where self-forgiveness and discernment started to connect for me.

As I began to forgive myself, I also began to see more clearly.

I wasn’t as clouded by fear or self-blame.

I could start to recognize what was actually safe… and what wasn’t.

Learning to trust myself wasn’t just about making decisions.

It was also about learning to discern people, relationships, and intentions more clearly.


Self-forgiveness became part of rebuilding trust.

This is still ongoing for me, still painful in moments and still something I’m learning how to surrender. I’m still learning what it looks like to fully forgive myself.

Because I had to stop seeing myself as the problem…

And start seeing myself as someone who was learning.

Learning to trust myself again meant learning to stop holding my past self to a standard she didn’t have the tools to meet.

What Helped Me Rebuild Self-Trust

A few things made a big difference:

Repetition

Making decisions over and over again—even small ones—helped retrain my thinking.

Safe People and a Safe Environment

Being around people who didn’t override or dismiss me gave me space to practice using my voice.

They were patient.

They were curious.

They didn’t rush me or answer for me.

They allowed space—and sometimes gently pushed me—to make decisions.

That combination made a huge difference.

This is also where learning to set boundaries began to matter.

Awareness

Recognizing when I was defaulting to old patterns helped me choose differently.


My Walk With God Changed This Too

A huge part of rebuilding self-trust has been rooted in my walk with God.

This didn’t come from arrogance or thinking I suddenly had everything figured out.

It came from becoming more steady in my identity in Him.

As I’ve grown deeper in my understanding of who God is, I’ve also begun to understand more of who I am.

And with that came something new:

The realization that I have a voice.

That it’s okay to speak up.
To make choices.
To have opinions.

They won’t always be perfect or correct.

But that doesn’t have to stop me anymore.

The more grounded I’ve become in who God is and who He says I am, the more freedom I’ve felt to live without fear—even in the small, everyday decisions.

Trusting myself now doesn’t feel separate from trusting God.

It has grown alongside it.


This Growth Didn’t Happen in Isolation

None of this changed in isolation.

It all worked together.

As I began to understand God more clearly, I also began to understand myself more clearly. As I learned more about my worth, I started to see why boundaries mattered. As I practiced boundaries, I grew in confidence. And as I grew in confidence, it became easier to trust myself.

It all moved together.

Without practicing my voice with safe people, I would not be as far along in trusting myself now. But without even a small amount of self-trust, I would not have been able to hold boundaries either.

That’s why all of this has gone hand in hand.

Identity, boundaries, self-worth, self-trust, and confidence did not grow separately for me. They grew together.

Healthy relationships played a role in this too.

And forgiveness was part of it as well.

And a huge part of that was community.

I needed good, solid people around me who would build me up, tell me the truth, and speak God’s truth over me when I struggled to hold onto it for myself.

That mattered more than I can explain.


Self-Trust Isn’t About Being Perfect

Trusting yourself doesn’t mean you’ll always get it right.

It means you’re willing to:

  • listen to yourself
  • make a decision
  • and stand in it

Even if it’s not perfect.


If You’re Learning to Trust Yourself Too

If this resonates with you, you might be:

  • afraid of making the wrong decision
  • used to deferring to others
  • unsure what you actually want
  • second-guessing yourself constantly

If that’s you, you’re not broken.

You may have just never been given the space to develop trust in yourself.

And that can change.


Where I’m At Today

Today, I trust myself more than I ever have.

Not because I have all the answers.

But because I’ve learned to:

  • listen to my own voice
  • make decisions
  • stay connected to myself
  • and stay grounded in God

Even when it feels uncomfortable.

And that’s something I’m still growing in.


FAQs

How do you trust yourself again after being controlled or shut down?
Rebuilding self-trust starts with small decisions, safe environments, and repetition. Over time, learning to listen to your own voice, set boundaries, and stay grounded helps restore confidence in your ability to make decisions.


Why do I struggle to make simple decisions?
If you were frequently corrected, dismissed, or controlled, your brain may have learned that making decisions isn’t safe. This can lead to overthinking, hesitation, and looking to others for validation—even in small choices.


Can you trust yourself and still trust God?
Yes. Trusting yourself doesn’t replace trusting God. As you grow in understanding God’s character and your identity in Him, it often becomes easier to trust your own voice, decisions, and discernment.


References

Biblical References:
The Holy Bible, Proverbs 3:5–6
The Holy Bible, 1 Corinthians 13:4–7

Clinical References:
American Psychological Association
The Body Keeps the Score
Polyvagal Theory

Leave A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top

Discover more from Empowered by Silence

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading