
When someone hurts us, changes toward us, controls us, shuts us out, or leaves important questions unanswered, one of the hardest things to let go of can be the need to understand why. We think if we could just make sense of what happened, maybe it would hurt less. Maybe we could forgive easier. Maybe we could finally stop replaying everything in our heads. But I am learning that sometimes healing requires us to stop chasing the why and start dealing with what we actually know, what we can actually change, and what God is asking us to do next.
Kayleena and I talk about the “why” more often than we probably should. Why did some relationships change so much? Why do some messages seem angry, cold, or distant to us now when things once felt so different? Why did concerns about our age difference turn into people saying I was controlling or manipulating her? Why did this blog create so much tension? Why have some conversations never happened and some questions gone unanswered?
We do have information. We know some people strongly disagree with our age difference. We know some people have said they believe I control or manipulate Kayleena. We know some people have been very upset about this blog. We have messages, memories, things people directly told us, and patterns we have watched for more than a year. But none of that means we know everything happening inside another person’s heart. I am starting to think one of the things God is asking me to surrender is not what happened, but my need to completely understand why it happened.
We Can See Patterns Without Knowing the Heart
Kayleena and I have gotten pretty good at recognizing patterns. We have watched how certain conversations tend to go, how people respond to certain subjects, and what often happens after particular boundaries are set. Sometimes we have even predicted what would happen next and been pretty close. There is value in paying attention because patterns can help us set realistic expectations, make wiser choices, and stop being surprised by the same behavior over and over.
But there is a line I need to respect. Recognizing a pattern is observation. Deciding I know the feelings or motives behind that pattern is interpretation. I may be able to predict someone’s response and still have no idea what is happening in their heart. Maybe it is anger. Maybe fear. Maybe hurt, embarrassment, concern, pride, confusion, or something I have never considered. I can have theories, but theories are not facts.
We can say, “That message sounded angry to us,” without saying we know the person was angry. We can say someone told us they disagreed with our age difference without deciding that explains every decision afterward. We can say someone was upset about the blog without saying the blog explains everything that followed. There is freedom in learning the difference between what I know and what I think might be true.
Our Minds Want to Fill in the Blanks
Psychologists sometimes call part of this a need for closure. Our minds like answers, and when something painful happens, especially with someone we love, “I don’t know” can feel unfinished. Research on the need for cognitive closure describes things like wanting predictability and feeling uncomfortable with ambiguity. When we are hurting, that empty space can make us want an explanation even when we do not actually have enough information to know the answer.
So we start filling in the blanks. Why did they do that? Why did they change? Why won’t they answer? What happened to make them this way? Why can’t they see what I see?
Sometimes we stop chasing the person but keep chasing the person in our head. I have written before about the pain of no longer chasing people, but I am realizing there is another kind of chasing that can continue long after the calls, texts, and attempts to fix things stop. We can keep chasing an explanation.
That is where thinking can turn into rumination, going over the same questions again and again without really getting anywhere. Thinking, praying, grieving, and trying to understand are not bad things, but there comes a point where nothing new is happening. I can say I gave somebody to God and then spend the next hour trying to solve them. That is not much of a surrender.
I Can Know What Happened Without Knowing Why
Giving up the why does not mean pretending something did not happen. I do not have to know why a conversation never happened to acknowledge that it never happened. I do not have to know why a message hurt to admit that it hurt. I do not have to understand someone’s motives before recognizing that trust has been damaged.
There is a very real example of this in our own lives. I do not have to know why Kayleena never received a response the rumors after being told there would be one. I can acknowledge that she was told a response would come and, as of now, it has not. I do not have to decide whether the reason was anger, avoidance, fear, hurt, not knowing what to say, or something else. The fact is enough for me to deal with what is actually in front of us.
That matters far beyond our story. If you are living in a controlling, hurtful, or confusing relationship, you do not need to understand why someone keeps yelling at you before admitting that being yelled at is hurting you. You do not have to understand why someone repeatedly ignores your boundaries before deciding you need stronger ones. You do not need to diagnose someone before recognizing manipulation, threats, intimidation, dishonesty, or a pattern that is damaging your peace. Understanding someone’s past may eventually give you compassion, but it does not require you to ignore what is happening in the present.
This is also where communication has limits. Healthy relationships need people who are willing to speak honestly and listen to each other. But as Kayleena wrote in Why Communication Doesn’t Always Heal Unhealthy Family Relationships, communication cannot force another person to understand, respond, or change.
Ask a Different Question
Maybe “Why are they doing this?” is not always the most useful question. Sometimes better questions are: What actually happened? What part do I know for certain, and what part am I guessing about? Is this relationship healthy and safe? What boundary may be needed? Who can I talk to who is trustworthy and wise? What is mine to own? What is not mine to carry? What is God asking me to do next?
Those questions give us something we can actually act on. If there is intimidation, coercion, threats, physical harm, or genuine fear for safety, the next step may also include getting outside help and making a safety plan. Stopping the search for someone’s motives should never mean ignoring danger.
Healthy communication also requires more than simply talking. The American Psychological Association notes that constructive communication includes listening, understanding another person’s point of view, and dealing with conflict without destructive patterns such as personal attacks or yelling.
I Still Need to Look at My Own Why
There is also a harder part for me. While I am asking why everyone else acts the way they do, I need to look at why I react the way I do. Why does being misunderstood bother me so much? Why did silence make me want to try again instead of accepting that someone was not answering? Why did I believe one more explanation might finally fix things? Why did wanting to protect my wife sometimes turn into anger? Why did I let other people’s opinions take up so much room in my head?
Celebrate Recovery has taught me to take inventory, but the inventory I am responsible for is mine. I cannot make somebody else explain themselves. I cannot make them apologize, change, understand, or take accountability. I can ask God to show me where I still need to grow, and that is work I can actually do.
Colossians 3 Gives Me Something Better to Chase
At church right now, we are going through a series called The Jesus Way, and we are studying Colossians 3. The timing feels pretty direct for me. I have spent a lot of time asking what other people are doing and why they are doing it, but Colossians 3 keeps turning the question back around: What is Jesus asking me to do?
Paul tells us to put on compassion, kindness, humility, gentleness, and patience. He tells us to bear with one another, forgive as the Lord forgave us, put on love, and let the peace of Christ rule in our hearts. That gives me something much better to chase than another person’s why. Am I being compassionate? Am I humble enough to admit that I may see the pattern without knowing the heart behind it? Am I being gentle instead of using truth like a weapon? Am I forgiving instead of feeding resentment? Is love leading me, or is frustration leading me? Is the peace of Christ ruling my heart, or are unanswered questions ruling it?
Colossians 3 also tells us to be thankful, and that matters because it is easy to become so focused on what is missing that we stop seeing what God has already given us. Kayleena and I have a marriage to care for. We have people who love us. We have church, recovery, friendships, laughter, opportunities to serve, and a life happening right in front of us. I do not want unanswered questions about other people to keep stealing attention from what God is doing here.
Then Colossians 3:17 raises the standard even more. Whatever we do, in word or deed, we are to do it in the name of Jesus. For me, that includes what I say about people who have hurt us. It includes what I write here. It includes how I respond to silence, disagreement, and things I believe are unfair. The question becomes less, “Can I prove I was right?” and more, “Does the way I respond look like Jesus?”
Forgiveness Does Not Require an Explanation
For a long time, I thought understanding might make forgiveness easier. Maybe if I knew why someone behaved a certain way, I could have more compassion and finally let go of the anger. But what happens if the explanation never comes? Some people may never explain themselves. Some may remember things differently. Some may believe they did nothing wrong. Some conversations may simply never happen. If I need every question answered before I forgive, I may be waiting forever.
Colossians 3:13 tells us to forgive as the Lord forgave us. That does not mean saying wrong behavior was okay. It does not mean pretending something did not hurt, and it does not mean immediately restoring trust. Forgiveness and access are not the same thing. I can forgive and still keep a boundary. I can pray for someone without chasing them. I can want God’s best for somebody while accepting that the relationship may not be healthy or close right now. For more on that distinction, How to Forgive Without Closure or Conversation goes deeper into forgiveness when the apology, explanation, or reconciliation never comes.
The goal is not to create boundaries out of revenge. It is to use wisdom without allowing bitterness to take over my heart.
Maybe I Really Don’t Need to Know
Kayleena and I may never fully understand why some relationships changed. We may never know why certain messages were written the way they were, why people came to certain conclusions about us, or why some conversations never happened. We may continue recognizing patterns, and those patterns can help us make wiser decisions, but they still do not give us access to another person’s heart.
Maybe we do not need it. Even if somebody handed me every answer tomorrow, my responsibility would still be the same. Love my wife. Follow Christ. Take my inventory. Own my mistakes. Make amends when needed. Forgive. Use wisdom. Keep healthy boundaries. Pray. Serve. Be thankful. Choose peace.
Romans 12:18 tells us, as far as it depends on us, to live at peace with everyone. Colossians 3 tells me what I want that to look like on my side: compassion, kindness, humility, gentleness, patience, forgiveness, love, peace, and thankfulness.
Sometimes the most truthful thing I can say is, “I have some information. I see some patterns. I have some ideas. But I really do not know why.” And I do not need to.
God, I don’t know why. You do. Help me take care of what You have asked me to do.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Do I Stop Chasing Why When Someone Is Still Hurting Me?
Start with what you actually know. Name the behavior without trying to explain the motive behind it. Ask whether you are safe, what boundaries are needed, and who can help you. You do not have to understand someone’s motives before taking a healthy next step.
Does Forgiving Someone Mean I Have to Stay in the Same Relationship?
No. Forgiveness does not automatically restore trust or require the same level of access. You can forgive while using wisdom, maintaining boundaries, and recognizing that some relationships may need distance.
What Do I Do When I Never Get an Explanation?
Accept what you know, acknowledge what you do not know, and turn your attention toward what is yours to do. Take your own inventory, seek wise help when needed, make healthy decisions, and ask God to help you release the part of the story that belongs to somebody else.
References
The Holy Bible: Matthew 7:3–5; Romans 12:18; Colossians 3:12–17.
Webster, D. M., & Kruglanski, A. W. (1994). Individual Differences in Need for Cognitive Closure. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 67(6), 1049–1062.
American Psychological Association. Happy Couples: How to Keep Your Relationship Healthy.
